History

The Penguins We Know Today Aren’t Penguins?! The Surprising Truth Behind The Great Auk

When you picture a penguin, you probably imagine a waddling black-and-white bird slipping along the ice in Antarctica, right? But here’s a twist that might surprise you: the birds we call “penguins” today are actually not true penguins at all!

The name we associate with these loveable little birds was borrowed from an entirely different species—the Great Auk—that’s been extinct for over a century. This curious case of mistaken identity isn’t just a quirky fact; it’s a story of exploration, tragedy, and human curiosity run amok.

So, sit tight, and let’s dive into the tale of how these two species became linked by more than just a name.

The Great Auk: The Real Penguins of History

Before our modern “penguins” got their famous moniker, the title actually belonged to an entirely different bird: the Great Auk (Pinguinus impennis). Great Auks were strikingly similar in appearance to the penguins we know today.

They had black-and-white plumage, stubby wings that were better for swimming than flying, and an endearing, clumsy waddle. But there were also some significant differences. Great Auks were larger than modern penguins, standing around 30 inches tall, and they made their homes not in the icy waters of the South Pole, but along the North Atlantic coast, from Europe to eastern North America.

great auk

photo: Wikipedia

The Great Auk lived comfortably along rocky coastlines, swimming through chilly waters and coming ashore only to breed. However, as time wore on, their existence came under threat—not from natural predators but from humans. For centuries, they were hunted for their meat, eggs, and feathers. Overhunting for resources alone drove the Great Auk population down significantly. But it was curiosity—and, tragically, our need for “specimens”—that sealed their fate.

The Extinction of the Great Auk

As European and American museums in the 19th century began collecting specimens from around the world to showcase and study nature’s diversity, rare animals were in high demand. For some collectors and museums, “extinct” specimens were considered highly valuable because they were viewed as irreplaceable treasures. Ironically, this mindset led to a rather dark consequence: when naturalists and collectors realized the Great Auk was becoming rarer, they increased their efforts to acquire them, effectively hastening their extinction.

One of the saddest parts of this story is the fate of the last known colony of Great Auks, found in Iceland in 1844. At this point, scientists and museums alike were well aware that Great Auks were on the brink of extinction. Instead of protecting the remaining birds, however, they decided to capture and kill them to preserve their bodies for display. In a tragic twist, the last two Great Auks ever seen were caught and killed while incubating an egg. Collectors took both birds and destroyed the egg, ensuring that no future Great Auks would survive. This final act marked the end of a species that had once flourished in the North Atlantic.

Penguins by Mistake: How Antarctic Birds Adopted the Auk’s Name

penguinsphoto: Wikipedia

While the Great Auk was facing its tragic end, explorers were venturing southward, encountering strange new lands and even stranger animals. When European explorers first came across the South Pole’s waddling birds in the 16th century, they couldn’t help but be reminded of the Great Auk. The resemblance was uncanny: flightless, black-and-white birds that awkwardly waddled on land but transformed into agile swimmers in the water. Because of this likeness, the explorers called them “penguins,” thinking they were a Southern Hemisphere version of the Great Auk. By the time they discovered these birds, the true penguin namesakes were already disappearing from the North.

Unlike the Great Auk, however, these Antarctic “penguins” had evolved in isolation for millions of years, far removed from their northern lookalikes. Scientists eventually determined that modern penguins, part of the family Spheniscidae, have no close relation to the Great Auk. Despite this, the name “penguin” stuck, and these Antarctic birds became the new face of the penguin name, while the original penguins faded into extinction.

The Word “Penguin”—What’s in a Name?

The name “penguin” itself is something of a mystery. Some linguists believe it may come from the Welsh words pen gwyn, meaning “white head,” a reference to the markings on the Great Auk’s head. This makes sense, as many Welsh sailors and fishermen would have been familiar with the Great Auk’s appearance along European coasts. Others theorize that it may derive from the Latin word “pinguis,” meaning “fat” or “plump,” which would certainly suit the look of both the Great Auk and modern penguins.

Regardless of its exact origin, the word “penguin” was attached to these southern birds due to the explorers’ initial mistake, and it has been passed down ever since. It’s a little odd if you think about it—after all, we’d never call ostriches “dodos” just because they’re both flightless birds!

From “Penguins” to Penguins: Why the Misnomer Endures

In the end, this case of mistaken identity doesn’t seem to have bothered our modern penguins one bit. They’ve thrived in the southern waters for millions of years, oblivious to the name they’ve borrowed from a long-extinct lookalike. And for us, it’s hard to imagine calling them anything else. The “penguin” name feels as much a part of these birds’ identity as their quirky personalities and distinguished tuxedo-like appearance.

Modern penguins may not be the true “penguins” of history, but they carry the legacy of the Great Auk, a bird that faced tragedy not for its inability to adapt to nature but due to human greed and curiosity. In a way, today’s penguins remind us of what was lost and hopefully prompt us to take better care of the creatures we share this planet with.

Remembering the Great Auk’s Legacy

While modern penguins swim the icy southern seas, the Great Auk’s story serves as a cautionary tale. It’s a reminder that the allure of “owning” nature’s rarities has consequences. Today, the taxidermied Great Auks that fill museum displays are some of the few remaining testaments to their once-thriving colonies, a chilling yet poignant symbol of a species that humans, ironically, sought to “preserve” by eliminating.

So, the next time you see a penguin, take a moment to appreciate the twist of history that brought this bird its name—and to remember the true penguins, the Great Auks, who walked a different shore long ago. In a strange way, our modern penguins have become ambassadors for their lost lookalikes. They may not be true “penguins” by the original definition, but they carry the name, along with a legacy that speaks to our responsibilities toward conservation and respect for all species.

Share via
Send this to a friend